In light of the ongoing assault on the independence of the judiciary in Poland by the ruling Law and Justice (PiS) party – and especially the recently-exposed hate campaign against judges and prosecutors, orchestrated by the justice ministry itself – the Renew Europe group and the Open Dialogue Foundation have organised on December 12th, 2019, a European Parliament lunch debate with prosecutors and judges persecuted in Poland.
The event was co-organised by Sophie in ‘t Veld MEP (RE, Netherlands) and Michal Šimečka MEP (RE, Slovakia), and featured:
- Judge Dariusz Mazur – Spokesperson of the Association of Judges “Themis”, against whom multiple disciplinary charges for defending the independent judiciary are pending;
- Judge Waldemar Żurek – former spokesperson of the National Judiciary Council (KRS) and most persecuted judge in Poland (including famously in the hate campaign against independent judges orchestrated by the justice ministry);
- Prosecutor Krzysztof Parchimowicz – President of the Board of the Association of Prosecutors “Lex Super Omnia”, against whom multiple disciplinary charges for defending the independent judiciary are pending;
- Prosecutor Ewa Wrzosek – Member of the Association of Prosecutors “Lex Super Omnia”, most persecuted female prosecutor in Poland with multiple disciplinary charges for defending the independent judiciary pending.
- Róża Thun MEP (EPP, Poland) – highly-popular Polish opposition MEP (awarded 3 MEP Awards for most hard-working MEP), very vocal on rule of law issues. Following her November 2017 vote in favour of invoking Article 7 against Poland she was symbolically strung from makeshift gallows in a public happening by far-right activists;
- Lyudmyla Kozlovska – co-founder and President of the Open Dialogue Foundation, an international NGO advocating for democracy, the rule of law and human rights in the post-Soviet area and the European Union. The Foundation and Lyudmyla herself are the target of a constant smear and defamation campaign from the PiS government, as well as the regimes of several post-Soviet states.
The event started with opening remarks by Michal Šimečka MEP (RE), who – despite being a first time MEP – already very well understands the gravity of the situation in Poland and laid it out for the guests.
It was followed by welcome remarks from Sophie in ‘t Veld MEP (RE), who is a leading defender of the rule of law and European values in the European Parliament and chairs the Civil Rights Committee’s Democracy, Rule of Law and Fundamental Rights Monitoring Group.
Last but not least, the participants were greeted by Lyudmyla Kozlovska, President of the Open Dialogue Foundation, who explained why this issue is so important for our foundation.
A more in-depth introduction to the rule of law crisis in Poland was then provided by well-known Polish EPP MEP Róża Thun.
The floor was then given to Judge Dariusz Mazur, spokesperson of the Themis Association of Judges, who gave a presentation on the Justice Ministry’s hijacking of the justice system and defamation campaign against disobedient judges.
Following judge Mazur, Judge Waldemar Żurek presented his own case, as he is often referred to as the most hated judge in Poland, as well as cases of his fellow judges from the Iustitia judges’ association.
Next, the topic shifted to the demolition of the institution of public prosecutor & repression against prosecutors, with a report presented by Prosecutors Ewa Wrzosek & Krzysztof Parchimowicz of the Lex Super Omnia association.
The opening statements were followed by a vivid discussion, starting with very kind words from Greens MEP Tinneke Strik, who congratulated the judges for their courage.
The whole Q&A session can be viewed on our YouTube channel.
Among our favourite fragments we have to thank the wonderful Róża Thun MEP for her kind words about ODF:
“The Open Dialogue Foundation reaches much further than the European Union, they’re active in Eastern Europe outside of the EU, in Central Asia and everywhere where people are being harassed for their political involvement and human rights are being broken. We have here Mr Kramek and Lyudmyla Kozlovska, and her story also is worth a book, and it’s not finished. I wish you a lot of courage, thank you very much for organising this, but you know what is characteristic, what’s going in in my beloved homeland – with ODF people from today’s government, Mrs Kempa, Mr Jaki, Saryusz-Wolski, Czarnecki etc, cooperated as far as I know, very well, with the Open Dialogue Foundation, up to the moment when the Foundation started criticising breaches of law in Poland, and then they underwent an incredible attack from the side of public media (which aren’t public any more) and from the side of the government. But you don’t give up, and please do not give up, continue your involvement, not only for Poland, it’s the whole Europe and further than that”,
but the most relevant quote to the current situation in Poland, has to go to Sophie in ’t Veld:
“If you don’t respect rulings of the CJEU, you should simply not be part of the European Union. It’s that simple. You want to be part of a club, you join and you play by the rules. If you want to be part of a football team, you cannot have your own rules, you have to play by the rules – otherwise don’t play football”.
It’s a sad takeaway from the debate, but unfortunately it is true what many experts are warning us about, that if the Polish government keeps excluding the country from the EU’s legal order it simply means that Poland is heading towards a Polexit. We must therefore do all we can to support the courageous judges and prosecutors who are often risking their careers to stop that from happening.
Following the event, several of the participants and speakers commented on the importance of the debate. Among the most noteworthy was Michal Šimečka MEP, who highlighted the courage of the judges and prosecutors:
Another speaker, Róża Thun MEP, quoted our guests judge Waldemar Żurek and prosecutor Krzysztof Parchimowicz, noting the persecution they face for performing their duties, including the quite shocking revelation that members of the prosecutors’ association, Lex Super Omnia, have been under surveillance since the association’s founding.
The entire debate as well as other selected fragments can be viewed on our Youtube channel.
- PACE adopts resolution on Poland with ODF’s amendments (04.02.2020)
- ODF holds a side-event on Polish judiciary during 2020 PACE Winter Session (03.02.2020)
- ODF welcomes persecuted Polish judges and prosecutors in Brussels (16.12.2019)
- Gazeta Wyborcza: Judges Waldemar Żurek and Dariusz Mazur in the European Parliament. They will tell about the deformation of the judiciary by PiS (01.12.2019)
- Position of the Open Dialogue Foundation in the case of Judge Dariusz Mazur (19.11.2019)
- 20 lawsuits filed against Law and Justice. Interim measure against TVP (11.10.2019)
- Attacks on judges and independent prosecutors in Poland. An ODF event at the OSCE forum (30.09.2019)
- A delegation of the ODF attended the Fourth part-session of PACE in Strasbourg (17.10.2018)
- PACE side event: Shrinking space for civil society and persecution of human rights activists (08.10.2018)
- ODF attends PACE Autumn Session 2018 to speak up for rule of law and human rights defenders (05.10.2018)
- Attack against the rule of law and civil society in Poland – a debate during the OSCE HDIM 2017 conference (19.09.2017)