On 4 March 2021 we organised an online hearing for Members of the European Parliament (MEPs), European Parliament advisors and selected journalists under the title “Law and Justice’s Crackdown on Independent Prosecutors in Poland Intensifies”, featuring persecuted Polish independent prosecutors from the Lex Super Omnia association – Katarzyna Kwiatkowska, Jacek Bilewicz and Ewa Wrzosek – with additional expertise provided by judge Dariusz Mazur.
The aim of the hearing was to deliver first-hand insights on the ongoing politicisation of the Public Prosecutor’s Office and harassment of independent prosecutors by the Polish authorities to MEPs monitoring the rule of law crisis in the country as a part of their mandate. This was especially important given the fact that – as opposed to matters related to the judiciary – threats to prosecutorial independence in Poland are often overlooked by the European institutions.
The event was co-hosted by MEPs:
- Katarina Barley – S&D, Germany, EP Vice-President, S&D shadow rapporteur on the EU Mechanism on Democracy, the Rule of Law and Fundamental Rights,
- Petri Sarvamaa – EPP, Finland, EP chief negotiator for the rule of law conditionality regulation;
- Terry Reintke – Vice-President of the Greens/EFA Group, Germany, co-coordinator of the Greens/EFA in the Committee on Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs (LIBE), LIBE rapporteur on the rule of law conditionality mechanism, Greens/EFA shadow rapporteur on the interim report on the rule of law in Poland;
- Łukasz Kohut – S&D, Poland, member of the Committee on Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs;
- Róża Thun – EPP, Poland.
The event’s main speakers were:
- Prosecutor Katarzyna Kwiatkowska – President (acting) of the Lex Super Omnia prosecutors’ association;
- Prosecutor Jacek Bilewicz – Lex Super Omnia Board Member;
- Prosecutor Ewa Wrzosek – Lex Super Omnia Review Board Member;
- Judge Dariusz Mazur – Spokesperson of the Themis Judges’ Association.
In their opening statements the MEPs stressed that the European Parliament is concerned about the Polish authorities’ continuous attacks on the rule of law which constitute a blatant disregard for EU values. It was also reiterated that, despite alarming signals coming from Poland, the European Commission has not been strict enough in standing up to the country’s democratic backsliding. As declared by the MEPs, the European Parliament will keep trying to counterbalance it and put pressure on the Commission to do more, including imposing additional infringement procedures. MEP Terry Reintke also expressed the hope that the hearing will feed into the new package of punitive measures that are currently being planned at the Commission level. All MEPs also offered words of support to independent prosecutors fighting for the rule of law in Poland, stressing they all stand by their side.
In their presentations the prosecutors described the most pressing challenges facing the prosecution service under the rule of the coalition formed by the Law and Justice party (PiS).
Lex Super Omnia President Katarzyna Kwiatkowska stated that the standards of the Polish prosecutorial system resemble more the Belarusian one than those of the EU. According to Kwiatkowska, the prosecution service is now concerned with political issues that are important to the ruling camp, as the prosecution of the opposition and of participants of anti-government protests. What’s more, its head – who is also an active politician and the head of a ruling coalition party – puts the political interest first, not that of the justice system.
After the ruling coalition’s changes to the prosecution service, the Prosecutor General was granted sweeping powers, including the power to intervene in investigations and the power to appoint and dismiss personnel on all levels. Although the authorities, says Kwiatkowska, justified these changes by the need of boosting the service’s effectiveness, the true aim was to carry out a large-scale personnel purge.
Kwiatkowska also described how the authorities apply a “stick and carrot” approach to subordinate the prosecution service. While prosecutors with little work experience or qualifications are kept in line by the prospect of easy and swift promotion and financial incentives, experienced, independent prosecutors are subjected to politically motivated disciplinary proceedings, demotions and punitive transfers.
Based on her own example, Ewa Wrzosek described the most recent, concrete harassment measures faced by independent prosecutors. In January 2021, together with six more Lex Super Omnia prosecutors, she was transferred far away from her previous posting and place of residence. She was given two days to pack her life and move to a city located over 300 km away from her home, where she is to spend the next six months separated from her children and family.
Apart from being subjected to a punitive transfer, prosecutor Wrzosek is also under several disciplinary proceedings. She put herself on the authorities radar by, among others, initiating an investigation into the organisation of the (eventually postponed) May 2020 presidential election involving, as potential key witness, top-level figures from the ruling camp, like PiS Chairman Jarosław Kaczyński or PM Mateusz Morawiecki. The investigation – as all investigations of suspected authorities’ wrongdoings – was immediately quashed.
An important point, showing that the politicisation of the prosecution service in Poland is not just a national issue, was raised by prosecutor Jacek Bilewicz. Bilewicz described how investigations uncomfortable to the authorities are being transferred to units that, under the law, are not territorially competent to conduct them. They are next passed to obedient prosecutors in a discretionary manner by a personal decision of a superior prosecutor. It is not uncommon for the leading prosecutor or a unit chief to be then promoted or receive a financial bonus. Importantly, as pointed out by prosecutor Bilewicz, many such investigations concern the EU directly, including proceedings regarding cases (offence notifications) reported by the European Anti-Fraud Office (OLAF) which are then ignored by the Polish authorities. The issue particularly sparked the interest of the hosting MEPs who pledged to look closer into it, taking this up with the Commissioner for Budget and Administration Johannes Hahn and the Director-General of OLAF, Ville Itälä.
Finally, judge Dariusz Mazur alerted the participants to the illegal actions undertaken by the Internal Department of the National Public Prosecutor’s Office, created to police the judicial and prosecution services, that has initiated blatantly political prosecutions like the case of 14 Cracow judges handing down judgments on reinstatement of Prosecutor Mariusz Krasoń that were inconvenient for the authorities.
See our rule of law activities within the EU institutions:
- ODF holds online hearing for MEPs with persecuted Polish judges (9 October 2020)
- World’s leading legal scholars in defence of judge Tuleya – ODF’s follow-up letter to the European Commission (9 June 2020)
- The decisive phase of the fight for the rule of law in Poland: an open letter to the European Commission (29 April 2020, in Polish)
- ODF among signatories of the letter to the President of EC regarding the breach of the rule of law in Poland (17 December 2019)
- “Law and Justice’s Campaign against Polish Judiciary” – ODF’s hearing in the European Parliament (17 December 2019)
- ODF welcomes persecuted Polish judges and prosecutors in Brussels (16 December 2019)
- Polish media about the conference organised by the ODF in the EP with the participation of persecuted Polish judges (13 December 2019)
See our other rule of law activities:
- Polish & Moldovan judges must remain independent. A firm resolution adopted by PACE (26 February 2021)
- How we fought for the rule of law in Poland: recap of our activities in 2020 (28 December 2020, in Polish)
- Position of the Open Dialogue Foundation in the case of Judge Dariusz Mazur (19 November 2019)
- Attacks on judges and independent prosecutors in Poland. An ODF event at the OSCE forum (30 September 2019)